The $4.5 million needle in the haystack

The 1937 Bugatti Type 57S Atalante sold by Bonhams earlier this month for a “royale” price of US$4,530,000 wasn’t shocking because it was one of 17 produced and was originally owned by the founder of the British Racing Drivers’ Club. Rather, the shocking bit comes that it sat in a barn, owned by doctor in Newscastle. Imagine the look on the person who first discovered this and actually KNEW its significance!
1884 into a privileged background and, following family tradition,
adopted a career with the Royal Navy after leaving school, serving as
a Battalion Commander of the 2nd Brigade Royal Naval Division in the
Great War, seeing action at Gallipoli and in Salonica, France and
Belgium. Upon cessation of hostilities the Rt. Hon. Viscount Curzon
entered politics, winning the Battersea South seat in London for the
Conservative Party in 1918, while still retaining his Naval
connections, taking up the rank of Captain and becoming Commanding
Officer of the Sussex Division of the Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve in
1921. He succeeded to the peerage in 1929 upon the death of his
father, becoming the 5th Earl Howe. This elevation to the peerage
ended his Parliamentary career and it was about this time that he
began his long and distinguished involvement in motor racing.
Howe’s place in the history of motor sport was assured by his victory
at Le Mans in 1931, driving an Alfa-Romeo and partnered on that
occasion by Sir Henry Birkin, completing 1,875 miles at an average
speed of 78.128mph. He was to drive at Le Mans on six occasions
between 1929 and 1935 and in his final year put in the fastest lap of
the race at a speed of 86.751mph, although sadly retiring after a hard
fought 1,087 miles.
Howe mixed with the ‘Bentley Boys’, Benjafield, Barnato, Kidston and
Birkin ranking amongst his close friends in motor racing circles. With
Howe’s support and encouragement Dudley Benjafield was to establish
the British Racing Drivers’ Club in 1928 and Howe was to be elected
its first President at the 1929 Annual General Meeting. He was a
regular at Le Mans and Brooklands, raced at Donington Park, winning
the Donington Park Trophy Race in 1933, carrying off the winner’s
laurels in the 1938 Grosvenor Grand Prix in South Africa and recording
many podium finishes in a racing career ending in 1939. Amongst pre-
war motor sport heroes, Earl Howe’s name ranked alongside those of
Campbell and Segrave – super heroes of their day who mixed in the
upper echelons of London’s high speed and fashionable society.
Howe, as Viscount Curzon, had driven a Type 43 Bugatti with some
success in the 1928 Ulster Tourist Trophy Race, achieving fastest lap
in Class D then sadly retiring with petrol supply problems, and
enjoyed mixed success on occasion partnering Campbell in a similar car
at Brooklands and other venues in 1929 and 1930. In 1931 he was to
secure delivery of one of the first Type 51 Grand Prix cars that he
was to campaign as an amateur in the 1931 Monaco Grand Prix. Howe’s
warm relationship with Le Patron is evidenced by the fact that he took
delivery of one of just a handful of the fearsome 4.9-litre
supercharged Bugatti Type 54 Grand Prix cars for the 1932 season.
Regrettably, the Type 54 failed to distinguish itself against the
might of Alfa Romeo, Mercedes-Benz and Maserati. Finally, in 1935,
Howe was to take delivery of a Works Team Bugatti Type 59, one of four
Grand Prix cars to be sold to British amateur drivers including
Martin, Eccles and Lewis when Le Patron scaled down factory racing
involvement. This pedigree of race cars, which Howe experienced at
first hand, undoubtedly influenced and spawned the Type 57S – surely a
Grand Prix car in touring car guise.
It is not surprising therefore that Howe, when choosing his personal
road car, would seek out the highest standards in road holding and
engineering refinement, maximum performance combined with comforts
that one of his social standing would expect, and an elegance
reflecting the very pinnacle of styling finesse in the mid-1930s.
Bugatti’s Type 57S ticked every one of those boxes – perhaps the
ultimate pre-war sports car. Its production run was but brief as
manufacturing costs were too high, however, Howe recognised the
outstanding nature of the beast. Bugatti’s Type 57 had already
established its credentials but although the 57S shared many of its
features, its differences set it in a league apart. Mechanical
excellence was achieved by fitting a modified crank case with dual oil
pumps and dry sump lubrication. High compression pistons gave the new
engine a significant performance edge and the clutch was reinforced to
cope with the extra output. Ignition was by a Scintilla Vertex magneto
driven from the left-hand camshaft. The fundamental difference between
the 57S and the standard 57 cars however lay in the frame design. The
new low-slung frame featured a shorter wheelbase, the rear axle
passing through the frame, while de Ram shock absorbers provided
damping cleverly engineered to increase with speed.
The new low-slung chassis and distinctive vee-shaped radiator design
of the 57S was a gift to the stylist and the Jean Bugatti-influenced
Atalante Coupé styling blended impeccably with the sculpted radiator
design.
It was not surprising that Bugatti should field a team of specially
designed 57S racing cars, winning in 1936 Le Grand Prix de l’A.C.F.,
le Grand Prix de la Marne and le Grand Prix du Comminges and setting
new One Hour, Six Hour and 24-Hour records at Monthléry. Notably Jean-
Pierre Wimille and Robert Benoist drove one of these cars to victory
at Le Mans in 1937 at an all time record average speed of 85.125mph
and covering 2,043 miles in 24 hours. With these credentials, little
wonder therefore that Howe’s car of choice in November 1936 was the 57S.
On 2nd November 1936 Bugatti factory ledgers recorded an order
(allocated no. 903) from their British agent, Col. Sorel, for a Type
57S Atalante Coupé for their valued client and Bugatti Owners’ Club
President, Earl Howe of Penn House, Amersham, Buckinghamshire. Perhaps
optimistically that order quoted a delivery date of 25th January 1937.
Chassis no. 57502 and engine no. 26S were allocated to this order.
Whatever the cause of the delay might have been, the factory-built
Atalante coachwork was not completed until 5th May 1937. It was
liveried in Howe’s racing colours of blue and black, furnished with
pig skin upholstery and equipped with twin spotlights and a split
front bumper. Bearing factory trade plate 1127 W5 the car was
photographed in the Alsatian countryside ( as illustrated here and
Bugatti – le pur-sang des automobiles, H G Conway, 1963, page 261) and
was finally road tested by Pierre Marco on 7th June 1937 prior to
delivery to Sorel on 9th June 1937. Old style buff log books from the
1940s and 1950s record first registration variously as 15th June 1937
and 15th July 1937. It seems likely that 15th June 1937 would be the
correct date of first registration as no doubt Howe was eager to road
test his new car, having ordered it some seven months previously. At
an early stage Howe equipped 57502 with distinctive rear view mirrors,
a luggage rack on the tail and replacing the split front bumper with a
single bumper and adding a similar rear bumper. Howe’s new car was
selected by Sorel for illustration in their next sales brochure, the
same photograph also featuring in the July 1937 issue of Bugantics.
Howe’s new car was registered DYK 5 and proudly displayed by him at
the Eastbourne Concours d’élégance on 20th July 1937. DYK 5 shared the
motor house at Howe’s Amersham home with a fine stable of other
European sports and racing cars and became a familiar sight in the
paddock at British motor sport venues. It is believed that the car was
stored at Penn House for the duration of the war, following which Howe
used this car, in his capacity as President of the British Racing
Drivers’ Club, to formally open the first British post-war motor sport
event, the Cockfosters Rally. Following an accident in 1945, Howe
replaced this car with his friend Lord Cholmondley’s Type 57C Atalante.
At the time of cataloguing in early January 2009, the precise
movements of 57502 was not recorded but correspondence on file
suggested that it passed via Car Mart Ltd of Euston Road, London, to
Continental Cars Ltd of Send, Surrey. However, on 1st January 2009 –
as a result of media exposure – Bonhams were contacted by a Mr R. M.
Oliver, who wrote in email correspondence,
“Having been the director of Continental Cars who dealt with the
purchase and subsequent re-sale of EWS 73, I was interested to
discover that it has re-appeared. Earl Howe sold it to the London
dealer, Car-Mart. When I went to see it in their showroom I was told
that the only alteration which had been made to the car was the
colour. Howe’s cars always incorporated his light blue, sometimes
referred to as “Howe blue”. It was a condition of the sale to Car-Mart
that it must not be sold in that colour, so they had the blue painted
maroon/dark red. I took the car for a short trial run and bought it
on behalf of Continental Cars Ltd.
I drove the car a number of times before selling to John P. Tingay, an
architect. When he came to collect it from us at Send he brought his
wife with him, and I was under strict instructions not to let her know
how much he had paid for it! About £2,000 or a bit more I think as
that is what 57S’s were making – a considerable amount of money in
those days. I am attaching a photograph of the car taken when
Continental Cars had it for sale.
R.M. Oliver.”
This email correspondence is now offered with the Bugatti and neatly
completes the continuous history. Other research indicates that in
September 1946 it was re-registered with the number EWS 73, the
original DYK 5 number being transferred to a Jaguar. And, as
previously mentioned, John P Tingay of Eastcote in Middlesex is
recorded as the owner of this car in early 1947, having acquired it
from the aforementioned Mr Oliver of Continental Cars.
In Bugantics in November 1948 Tingay records the fitting of a Marshall
K200 supercharger and modified manifolding, effectively upgrading the
car to Type 57SC specification. The next recorded owner on 13th
January 1950 was Metal Castings Ltd of Worcester, whose director,
Marmaduke Harry Ferguson of Stanklyn House, Stone, Kidderminster,
became the recorded owner on 19th March 1951. On 31st December 1953
this car was recorded in the ownership of Matthew White Ridley, the
3rd Viscount Ridley, of Blagdon Hall, Seaton Burn, near Newcastle.
Ridley would of course have been a close acquaintance of Howe in
racing circles in pre-war days, having actively campaigned Alfa-Romeos
and indeed developed and built his own Ridley Special to compete with
Herbert Austin’s diminutive supercharged racing cars. Ridley’s
ownership of this car was comparatively brief, but during that
ownership it was most probably seen regularly in Newcastle-upon-Tyne
by Dr Harold Carr whose family had business interests in that city.
Dr Carr had a passion for the finer things in life and had no doubt
followed the motor racing exploits of the likes of Howe and Ridley in
pre-war years. His choice of a Type 57S was deliberate and, prior to
acquisition of 57502, he had already corresponded with J H Bartlett
Ltd, Sports and Competition Car Specialists of Notting Hill Gate,
regarding 57573, the ex-Abecassis 1937 London Show car. He had also
corresponded with Peter Thorneycroft, President of the Board of Trade,
in February 1955 regarding the possibility of importing a Type 57 from
Belgium. Perhaps it was no coincidence that 57502 returned to
Newcastle when Dr Carr bought the car for £895 from J H Bartlett Ltd
in April 1955.
History does not record to what extent Dr Carr used 57502 but
correspondence on file suggests that he spent some time trying to
enhance the performance of the de Ram shock absorbers and Scintilla
ignition. It seems likely that the car saw little use during the
doctor’s ownership and the present recorded mileage of 26,284 miles
may well be correct, bearing in mind the laid up period during the War
and the fact that the car is known to have remained in a partially
dismantled state in the doctor’s garage for 50 years or so in
preparation for a full rebuild. That rebuild was destined not to happen.
The doctor’s very private nature resulted in 57502 remaining largely
out of sight until his death in the late Spring of 2007. Recent
careful cleaning and conservation and refitting of various ancillaries
clearly shows the absolute integrity of this significant emerging
motoring icon, with all major components being original to the car and
the original body number, always thought to be no. 9, now confirmed by
visible bonnet valance stampings and stampings to the rear wheel spats.
A new owner now has the opportunity to carefully retain the present
patina or to carry out a sympathetic restoration, starting from an
outstandingly original baseline. It is thought that the engine of
57502 has not been fired up for more than 50 years and, following
stripping and rebuilding, the new owner will have the pleasure of
firing up 26S and hearing that turbine-like sound that so excited Earl
Howe when he collected this car from Sorel in 1937. Once again 57502,
a true supercar with impeccable credentials, emerges to take its place
on the world stage.
The car’s discovery has been brought to the attention of the Pebble
Beach Concours d’Elegance selection committee, and they have kindly
granted the car a fully transferable entry in its present condition
(and subject to their entry criteria) for the Pre-war Preservation
class of their 2009 event, which is available to the new owner.
Sold for €3,417,500 inclusive of Buyer’s Premium
For more information, check out these links:
http://blog.wired.com/cars/2009/02/a-1937-barn-fin.html
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/7876741.stm






